📋 Case Study

Ammonia Refrigeration System HAZOP & LOPA Integration at Midwest Food Processing Plant

Unplanned releases during maintenance due to undocumented isolation points and missing P&IDs

🏗️ Project Overview

Retrofit of legacy ammonia chiller system serving 300k sq ft food processing facility

🎯 Challenge

Unplanned releases during maintenance due to undocumented isolation points and missing P&IDs

🔧 Design Approach

Integrated HAZOP-LOPA workshop with operations team; added dual-block-and-bleed valves, automated lockout logic, and real-time NH₃ monitoring with 50 ppm alarm threshold

📐 Design Diagram

NH₃ CompressorDual-Block-&-Bleed ValveAuto Lockout LogicUndocumented Isolation Points(Missing P&IDs)NH₃ Monitor50 ppm AlarmSIL 2Dispersion Radius = 320 m (ERPG-2)HAZOP-LOPA Integrated Workshop • Midwest Food Processing Plant

AI-generated project design illustration

📐 Key Calculations

SIL Target

LOPA-derived frequency × consequence multiplier
Result: SIL 2
Defined SIS architecture requirements

Dispersion Radius (ERPG-2)

PHAST Gaussian model with 99th percentile wind data
Result: 320 m
Informed emergency response zone planning

📊 Results

Zero unplanned releases over 3 years; 47% reduction in PHA rework cycles; OSHA VPP Star certification achieved

💡 Lessons Learned

  • Cross-functional PHA participation improves detection of procedural hazards
  • Real-time gas monitoring validates dispersion models
  • SIL assignment must reflect actual proof test discipline

Key Takeaways

  • 1Cross-functional PHA participation improves detection of procedural hazards
  • 2Real-time gas monitoring validates dispersion models
  • 3SIL assignment must reflect actual proof test discipline